Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Eric Brand's avatar

"Critics highlight the significant gap of about 500 years between the time of the supposed miracles described in the Torah and when the Torah was written, according to secular scholars. " This is the crux of the issue. The Kuzari's argument doesn't rely on secular scholars. It relies on trust in an unbroken chain of transmission. Considering the incredible scholarship of the those trusted with the transmission, the cross-checking between different communities, and the general suspicion of all novelty, the burden of proof is on the late-comers and outsiders. And as we've seen in recent history, that scholarship is subject to continued revision, generally in favor of the insiders' tradition. So I'll take this article's points with a grain of salt and declare myself unpersuaded.

Expand full comment

No posts